Wednesday, January 04, 2012

Ranking The Marvel Movies

When I was a teenager there was no such thing as the Internet and we got our rumors and possibilities from magazines and comic books. In the middle of Marvel comics in the 70s and into the 80s there was a letters page and shortly after that there was the Bullpen Page. On the Bullpen Page I remember there being some announcements of a Fantastic Four movie and then some time later, intimations of a possible Silver Surfer movie. The FF film eventually became the version that Roger Corman shot and I never heard about a Surfer picture.

There were two notable TV series in the late 70s, one about Spider-Man and the infinitely superior The Incredible Hulk with Bill Bixby. If I remember correctly, there was a pilot for PowerMan, too, but it wasn't the Luke Cage PowerMan and so I didn't pay attention to that. Various cartoons including a Fantastic Four series and Spider-Man and his Amazing Friends came and went but no movies.

Then in 2002 there was Sam Raimi's Spider-Man. Wow. As Spidey swung through the canyons Manhattan in that movie I was ten years old. Despite the obvious problems of plot and casting, the execution of Spider-Man was a high point. I really liked it. It didn't compare at all to the best superhero film of all time (Superman II [The Dark Knight hadn't been released yet and stands on par with Superman II for me]), but it looked like we were heading for a new era of superhero movies.

Marvel has put out quite a few more live action films than DC has and that means that the law of averages has taken over. There's quite of bit of dreck from Marvel out there (Daredevil, Elektra, Ghost Rider, Spider-Man 3, the Punisher movies) but some real gems, too. I haven't seen them all, but I've seen the good ones. Here then is my completely subjective and very personal list of how I think of the Marvel films.

BEST OF THE BUNCH: X-Men, Iron Man 2, Thor, Captain America, Iron Man, Blade, Thor

MIDDLE OF THE PACK: The Incredible Hulk, Blade 2, Fantastic Four, X2

BOTTOM OF THE BARREL: Daredevil, Elektra, Ghost Rider, Spider-Man 3, Punisher (both 1989 and 2003 versions), Hulk, Punisher: War Zone, Howard the Duck, Blade: Trinity, Fantastic Four: Rise of the Silver Surfer, X-Men: the Last Stand

STILL TO BE DETERMINED: X-Men: First Class, Man-Thing, X-Men Origins: Wolverine.

Though they're grouped, they are not in any particular order. You'll notice that with the exception of The Incredible Hulk (a film I particularly liked but is realistically not as good as the others), the Marvel Studios films are the cream of the crop.

However, none of these films approaches The Dark Knight for making believable superheroes come to life. Superman II is still a cut above even thirty-plus years later. This isn't a list of the best comic book adaptations, just my feelings about the Marvel films I've seen. I hope that The Avengers continues the winning record of the Marvel Studios stuff. If they continue to hire excellent directors and spend the money and time to write a GREAT story, they will.

That hasn't been the track record to date, though. Time will tell, I suppose. In the meantime, I'm looking forward to The Avengers and The Dark Knight Rises (a title I dislike) this summer. Sooner or later, I'll rank the DC movies, too, and the best comic book adaptations.

In closing today, I'd really like to see a DC film of Sandman Mystery Theater. If DC were after a potentially viable franchise, I would think that would be a great place to look. I'd like to see a Nick Fury, Agent of SHIELD movie based on the Steranko stuff, too. That's a franchise waiting to happen. All speculation and wishful thinking on my part, though. What do I know about movies?

3 comments:

KansasBard said...

So.. Thor is listed twice. Did you like it twice as much?

In general, I agree with your groupings. However, I think the strongest of the X-Men films is X2. Although X-Men: First Class gives it a run for its money.

It's amazing to me that I've seen so many of the Marvel movies, despite my reservations about most of them. I still haven't seen Punisher: War Zone, Blade: Trinity, or Man-Thing. We should probably get together and have a Mighty Marvel Marathon.

Jason Arnett said...

I liked Thor a LOT. Twice as much as the others? Eh - probably not. I really want to watch First Class, just haven't gotten to it, yet.

I like that the adaptations were TURE adaptations from one medium to another and that they didn't give in to hokey dialogue as much as they might have.

I like the idea of a Marvel marathon. We'll have to work that out.

Mike Sullivan's Virtual Infinity Comics Blog said...

Okay, you REALLY, I mean REALLY don't want to see Man-Thing. REALLY.

After you see it, you'll understand, if you can get all of the way through it.

I'd watch other things first. Like paint drying.